Home › OUR EDITORIAL PROCESS
The Family Film Collection

Our Editorial Process

How a film becomes part of the collection.

A recommendation carries responsibility.

Someone may choose a film because of something we have written. A parent may use our age guidance. A teacher may introduce a title to a class. A family may spend an evening together because we pointed them toward a film they had never seen.

That is why every entry follows a considered editorial process.

1. Viewing

2. Observation

Notes are made about story, characters, pacing, visual language, humor, tone, relationships and other details that give the film its identity.

3. Research

Production information, release history, cultural context and relevant factual details are checked against reliable sources.

4. Family context

The film is considered from the perspective of different audiences and ages, including content that parents or educators may want to understand beforehand.

5. Editorial evaluation

The film is considered in relation to the wider collection.

Its strengths, limitations, originality, cultural context and reasons for inclusion are examined.

Editorial Standing adjudication

A Film or TV Series receives its Editorial Standing after editorial evaluation. It is calibrated against comparable works of the same kind, intended audience and purpose, and checked for consistency across the wider collection before being finalized. Films are not ranked against unrelated TV Series, and preschool works are not judged against titles made for older audiences.

6. Writing

The entry is written specifically for that film.

There is no fixed formula for making every title sound the same.

7. Review

The completed entry is reviewed for factual accuracy, clarity, specificity, repetition and consistency with the editorial standards of the collection.

8. Updating

The collection can be corrected and refined when reliable new information becomes available.

The goal is not to create the appearance of certainty.

The goal is to create a resource families can use with confidence.